Ethical and moral issues in human pluripotent stem cell ucla ctsi. Rapid progress in biotechnology has introduced a host of pressing ethical and policy issues pertaining to stem cell research. International stem cell forum ethics working party et. Our hope is that stem cell scientists and clinicians will use the information presented herein as a. Ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy stem cell. Review ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy. Our hope is that stem cell scientists and clinicians will use the information presented herein as a starting point for more indepth analysis of ethical and safety issues related to clinical translation of stem. In the case of embryonic stem cell research, it is impossible to respect both moral principles. Key ethical issues in embryonic stem cell research comparing the benefits and harms of alternatives to embryonic stem cell research adult stem cell research whether destructive embryonic stem cell research is the right thing to do or not, will partly depend on what the alternatives are, and how their particular benefits and drawbacks balance out. Human embryonic stem cell research has elicited powerful debates about the morality of destroying human embryos. Religion and the public ethics of stemcell research plos. Different countries have chosen to regulate embryonic stem cell research in very different ways.
Human stem cell research holds promise for combating some of the most recalcitrant of diseases and for regenerating damaged bodies. We have examined the ethical issues raised by the potential of stem cells derived from donated embryos, embryos created specifically for research purposes. A clear majority says that embryonic stem cell research either is morally. However, human stem cell hsc research also raises sharp ethical and political controversies. Ethical issues in stem cell research pubmed central pmc. There is generally very little concern about research with nonhuman embryonic or 10, research, in c r. They also raise many questions with social and ethical implications. Ethical issues in human embryonic stem es cell research the status of the human embryo page 14 donating embryos page 18 federal funding for human embryonic stem es cell research page 20 opinions page 23 other ethical issues page 25 part iii. Review ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy nancy mp king1 and jacob perrin2 abstract rapid progress in biotechnology has introduced a host of pressing ethical and policy issues pertaining. Williams specialist in public health and bioethics domestic social policy division judith. Our hope is that stem cell scientists and clinicians will use the information presented herein as a starting point for more indepth analysis of ethical and safety issues related to clinical translation of stem cells since controversial regulation and application of stem cell therapy has been falsely celebrated not only in countries with lax.
But what exactly are the ethical arguments and why are they so tricky. That milestone marked the start of a scientific and public fascination with stem cells, not just for their biological properties but also for their potentially transformative medical uses. The next two decades of stem cell research animated an array of bioethical debates, from the destruction of embryos to derive. Ethical issues adobe pdf view as html order code rl33554 stem cell research. Ethical and social considerations of stem cell research. Ethical issues relating to the sources of human embryonic stem or embryonic. Stem cells are undifferentiated biological cells that can differentiate into specialized cells. Stem cell research has been extremely controversial. We draw on a sample of the bioethics and scientific literatures to address issues that are specific to stem cell research and therapy. Ethical issues in stem cell research oxford academic journals. Although the proven benefits of stem cell research are somewhat limited according to current science, the future. Mention embryonic stem cells in the pub and the topic still divides opinion. Both hes cells and hips cells have the potential to form teratomas tumours characterized by the presence of cells corresponding to all three embryonic germ layers if transplanted into patients 3, 4 and the risk of tumorigenesis 3, 57. It has been 20 years since the first derivation of human embryonic stem cells.
Key ethical issues in embryonic stem cell research. Ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy stem. Review ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy nancy mp king1 and jacob perrin2 abstract rapid progress in biotechnology has introduced a host of pressing ethical and policy issues pertaining to stem cell research. Stem cells are undifferentiated biological cells that can differentiate into specialized cells and can divide through mitosis to produce more stem cells. The advantages and disadvantages of stem cell research go beyond the ethics of this field.
Executive summary national bioethics advisory commission georgetown university september 1999 ethical issues in human stem cell research. Ethical and social issues surrounding stem cell research ethics white papers produced by the canadian stem cell network. On one hand adhering to general principles of research ethics in stem cell researches has a great importance. Focusing on human embryonic stem es cells page 11 part ii. Ethical issues in genetics premarital counseling, genetic testing, genetic engineering, cloning and stem cell therapy, dna fingerprinting the progenyislamic views the main relevant ethical aspects related to care for the family unit in islam can be summarized as follows. Encourage nurses as individuals and as a professional community to maintain awareness of the practice outcomes translated from stem cell research and respond appropriately. With any hsc research, however, there are difficult dilemmas, including consent to donate materials for hsc. Chapter 3 is an indepth exploration of the ethical issues, especially those concerning the early human embryo. The recent development of induced pluripotent stem cells ipscs and related technologies has caught the attention of scientists, activists, politicians, and ethicists alike. One major ethical catch in the production of patientspecific therapies and personalized medicine, however, is its cost. Executive summary was published in september 1999 by the us national bioethics advisory commission in response to a national debate about whether or not the us federal government should fund embryonic stem cell research. Oct 28, 2014 human stem cell research holds promise for combating some of the most recalcitrant of diseases and for regenerating damaged bodies. Cell stem cell forum ethical and legal issues arising in research on inducing human germ cells from pluripotent stem cells tetsuya ishii,1, renee a.
To ensure appropriate selection of the members of the legal. Embryonic stem cells offer hope for new therapies, but their use in research has been hotly debated. These include particular issues involving different types of cells used, the procurement of such cells, in vivo use of stem cells, intellectual property, and conflicts. It is a great resource for anyone with a biological background seeking intelligent arguments in support of stem cell research. The ethical issues provides detailed descriptions of the arguments adopted by proponents of stem cell research. T he collection of tissue from one individual for therapeutic use in another individual involves not only technical and. Our hope is that stem cell scientists and clinicians will use the information presented herein as a starting point for more indepth analysis of ethical and safety issues related to clinical translation of stem cells. Jun 22, 2018 it has been 20 years since the first derivation of human embryonic stem cells. More americans consider embryonic stem cell research to be morally acceptable than say the same about having an abortion. And yet the use of these special cells is quite controversial because of where they come from. In order to identify these highest standards and define the practices that will make it possible for the stem cell research community to abide by them, meetings are necessary that foster education and. Pdf resolving ethical issues in stem cell clinical trials.
Only about a fifth of the general public 22% considers embryonic stem cell research morally wrong. Ethical challenges regarding the use of stem cells. Moral status the derivation of stem cells from aborted fetuses raises the issue of the relevance of the morality of induced abortion to stem cell research. Stem cell research holds great potential for better medical treatments and cures but is also plagued with controversies related to sourcing of embryonic stem cells, ethical debates about the personhood of embryos, and fears due to misconceptions about the processes of stem cell research and treatment in general. Summary of some ethical issues in human stem cell research. In order to identify these highest standards and define the practices that will make it possible for the stem cell research community to abide by them, meetings are necessary that foster education and deliberation among stem cell researchers, patients, bioethicists, regulatory officials and others about the complex and often novel ethical. Ethical issues in human embryonic stem es cell research the status of the human embryo page 14 donating embryos page 18 federal funding for human embryonic stem es cell. The ethical, legal and political minefield of stem cell. Establishing a national hematopoietic stem cell bank program. Ethical issues in the induced pluripotent stem cell era. Stem cell research will have a significant impact on health and the. Executive summary was published in september 1999 by the us national bioethics advisory commission in response to a national debate about whether or not.
Key ethical issues in embryonic stem cell research comparing the benefits and harms of alternatives to embryonic stem cell research adult stem cell research whether destructive embryonic stem cell. The derivation of pluripotent stem cell lines from oocytes and embryos is fraught with. Several issues should be addressed now, even though phase i clinical trials. Scientific progress in human embryonic stem cell hesc research and increased funding make it imperative to look ahead to the ethical issues generated by the expected use of hescs for transplantation. The first phase is the donation of biological material, highlighting the problem of informed and voluntary consent 2. Stem cell research holds great potential for better medical treatments and cures but is also plagued with controversies related to sourcing of embryonic stem cells, ethical debates about the personhood of. Fewer see stem cell research and ivf as moral issues. This is followed by a section on the legal aspects of stem cell research, both from a national and international. Stem cell ethicsinternational stem cell registry at umass. Some type of embryo stem cell research is permissible in virtually every state. That milestone marked the start of a scientific and public fascination with stem cells, not just for their.
Ethics and induced pluripotent stem cells the embryo. Ethical and safety issues of stem cellbased therapy. It is a great resource for anyone with a biological background. Pdf european scientific, ethical, and legal issues on human. Stem cells hold the promise of helping us treat a host of diseases and conditions, from spinal cord injuries to parkinsons. This kind of stem cell bank would require the creation of embryos from gamete donors who share the same hlatypes i. Stem cells hold great promise in helping us understand and treat many human diseases and conditions. Properties the classical definition of a stem cell. Stem cell report archived websites at the bioethics research. The international stem cell forum iscf supports research on all stem cell types, including adult stem cells, embryonic stem cells, and stem cells from umbilical cord blood.
Summary of some ethical issues in human stem cell research i. Encourage nurses as individuals and as a professional community to maintain awareness of the practice outcomes. Wayne hall, democracy and embryonic stem cell research. The second phase, research with human embryonic stem cells, creates several ethical issues. Several other methods of deriving stem cells raise fewer ethical concerns. To obtain embryonic stem cells, the early embryo has to be destroyed. Thats because stem cells are quite unique compared to other types of cells. Ethical issues in the induced pluripotent stem cell era did you know that. Patientspecific therapies have been the goal of many stem cell researchers, as such therapies would be less subject to the recipients immunorejection of foreign cells, implants, or treatments. Related ethical issues may be discussed using different ethical approaches, such as. The ethical, legal and political minefield of stem cell research. However, there are important ethical issues related to stem cell research that are. Pdf resolving ethical issues in stem cell clinical. Corrigan, oonagh, kathleen liddell, john mcmillan, alison stewart and susan.
Pdf european scientific, ethical, and legal issues on. At present, the best way to address the therapeutic problem is through the creation of a public stem cell bank that represents a genetically diverse pool of stem cell lines faden et al. Each approach may justify or reject the use of stem cells in research or therapeutics. Both hes cells and hips cells have the potential to form teratomas tumours characterized by the presence of cells corresponding to. European scientific, ethical, and legal issues on human stem cell research and regenerative medicine. Apr 14, 2009 however, human stem cell hsc research also raises sharp ethical and political controversies. Despite the potential stemcell research holds, many people across the world find it controversial and raise various ethical issues that prevent the research from continuing and flourishing. The derivation of pluripotent stem cell lines from oocytes and embryos is fraught with disputes regarding the onset of human personhood and human reproduction. Pdf ethical issues in stem cell research and therapy. A clear majority says that embryonic stem cell research either is morally acceptable 32% or is not a moral issue 36%. Related ethical issues may be discussed using different ethical approaches, such as utilitarianism, deontology, and principlism.
Stemcell research and ethical dilemmas for policy makers. There should be a sound scientific justification for using human oocytes and embryos to derive new human stem cell lines. However, there are important ethical issues related to stem cell research that are unrelated to embryo destruction. It is also an ethical, legal and political minefield. Review ethical and safety issues of stem cellbased therapy. This is followed by a section on the legal aspects of stem cell research, both from a national and international perspective chapter 2. Advances in stem cell research offer unprecedented insights into human biology and opportunities for clinical translation.
Resolving ethical issues in stem cell clinical trials. Ethics of stem cell research stanford encyclopedia of. Embryonic stem cell research poses a moral dilemma. Ethical issues in research using stem cells derived from ex utero, nonviable human fetal tissue. Ethical issues at different phases of stem cell research.
681 522 46 930 1184 79 1419 506 66 1324 1094 1185 407 1075 799 531 1007 427 273 1091 932 66 1373 305 591 202 686 39 261 134 328 94 621 24 1334 138 1055 1079 1034 677 1106 90 407 363 1235